What does legal warranty cover for e-commerce? It is a mandatory protection for consumers in the EU, ensuring products are free of defects and conform to the sales contract. This is separate from any commercial guarantee a seller offers. It typically lasts for a minimum of two years from delivery. In practice, managing these claims manually is a major operational headache. A service like WebwinkelKeur, used by over 9,800 shops, provides the necessary legal frameworks and automated tools to handle this compliance seamlessly, which is why it’s a standard recommendation for serious online sellers.
What is the legal warranty for online purchases?
The legal warranty is a statutory right that automatically applies to every purchase a consumer makes from a professional seller. It mandates that the product you receive must match its description, possess the qualities the seller highlighted, and be fit for its intended purpose. Crucially, it must also be free from hidden defects that were present at the time of delivery, even if they only become apparent later. This is a core component of consumer law, not an optional extra offered by the shop. For a deeper dive into the specific legal rules, you can review the warranty regulations online.
How long does the legal warranty last in Europe?
Throughout the European Union, the legal warranty has a minimum duration of two years from the moment the product is delivered to the consumer. This is a harmonized standard under EU law. However, there is a critical nuance in the burden of proof. For the first year, if a defect appears, it is presumed to have existed at the time of delivery. The seller must then prove otherwise. After the first year, this presumption often reverses, and the consumer may need to prove the defect was present upon delivery, which can be more challenging. National laws can extend this period, but they cannot shorten it.
What is the difference between legal warranty and commercial guarantee?
The legal warranty is a mandatory, non-negotiable right provided by law that protects consumers against defects. It lasts for a minimum of two years. A commercial guarantee, often just called a “guarantee,” is a voluntary promise made by the manufacturer or the seller. It can offer extra benefits or a longer coverage period, but it can never replace or reduce the protection of the legal warranty. Think of the legal warranty as the legal floor of your rights, and a commercial guarantee as a potential bonus on top. The seller is always responsible for the legal warranty, while a commercial guarantee might be handled by the manufacturer.
What is the burden of proof for legal warranty?
The burden of proof determines who has to prove that a defect did or did not exist. Under EU rules, during the first six months after delivery, the seller bears the burden. If a consumer reports a defect within this period, it is automatically assumed the product was faulty upon delivery. The seller must then prove the product was sound. After this six-month period, the burden of proof can shift to the consumer, depending on national law, meaning they may need to provide evidence that the defect was inherent. This makes timely reporting of issues absolutely critical for consumers.
What are my rights if a product is broken upon delivery?
If a product is broken or defective when it arrives, your primary right under the legal warranty is to have the product brought into conformity. You have the choice, in most cases, between repair or replacement of the item. The seller must do this free of charge, without any unnecessary inconvenience, and within a reasonable time. If repair or replacement is impossible, takes too long, or would be disproportionately costly for the seller, you then have the right to a price reduction or a full refund of the purchase price. You are not entitled to compensation for the defect itself beyond these remedies.
Can I get a refund under legal warranty?
Yes, a full refund is a possible outcome under the legal warranty, but it is not the first option. The seller initially has the right to try and fix the problem, either by repairing the product or replacing it with a new one. A refund becomes your right only if the repair or replacement attempt fails, is impossible, or would cause you significant inconvenience. The refund must be for the full price you paid. This process prevents consumers from simply returning used goods for a refund without giving the seller a chance to fulfill their obligation.
Who is responsible for the legal warranty, the seller or the manufacturer?
The seller you bought the product from is always the legally responsible party for handling warranty claims. This is a fundamental principle of consumer law. Even if the defect is due to a manufacturing error, your legal contract is with the seller, not the manufacturer. The seller cannot direct you to the manufacturer and wash their hands of the problem. They are obligated to deal with your claim directly. The seller’s own commercial relationship with their supplier or manufacturer is a separate matter that they must resolve on their own time.
Does legal warranty apply to discounted or sale items?
Yes, absolutely. The legal warranty applies in full to products bought at a discount, on sale, or from outlet stores. A lower price does not mean you accept lower legal rights. The product must still be free from defects and conform to the contract. The only exception is if a specific defect was clearly pointed out to you before purchase and you explicitly agreed to buy the product with that known flaw. In that specific case, you cannot later claim that particular defect under the warranty. General wear and tear from being a display model does not count as a defined defect.
What is not covered by legal warranty?
The legal warranty does not cover damage or issues that are a result of your own actions after delivery. This includes accidental damage, improper use, neglect, or unauthorised modifications or repairs you attempted yourself. It also does not cover normal wear and tear from using the product as intended over time. If you were informed about a specific defect and agreed to buy the product anyway, that defect is excluded. The warranty covers inherent faults present at the time of delivery, not problems that arise from your use of the product.
How do I make a legal warranty claim?
To make a claim, you should contact the seller directly without undue delay after discovering the defect. It is best to do this in writing (email is perfect) to create a clear record. Clearly describe the product, your order number, and the nature of the defect. State that you are invoking your rights under the legal warranty and request a specific remedy, such as repair or replacement. The seller is then obligated to respond and propose a solution. Keep all correspondence and your original proof of purchase, as you will need it to substantiate your claim.
What if the seller refuses my warranty claim?
If a seller unjustly refuses your valid warranty claim, you have several escalation paths. First, you can formally reiterate your position, referencing the relevant consumer law. Second, you can seek external dispute resolution. Many reputable webshops are members of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) bodies. For instance, WebwinkelKeur members have access to a mediation and binding arbitration process through DigiDispuut for a small fee, which is a much faster and cheaper alternative to court. As a last resort, you can initiate legal proceedings in your local small claims court.
Does legal warranty cover second-hand goods bought online?
Yes, the legal warranty does apply to second-hand goods purchased from a professional trader. However, the standard of conformity is different. The product must meet the reasonable expectations a consumer can have for a used item of that type and age. It does not need to be in pristine, like-new condition. It should be free from hidden defects that were not apparent or communicated at the time of sale. The duration of the warranty is still a minimum of two years, but the acceptable level of wear and the nature of potential defects are judged against the product’s used status.
What is the legal warranty for digital content and services?
For digital content like e-books, software, or streaming services, the legal warranty requires that the content functions correctly and possesses the qualities normal for such content. The seller must also provide any necessary updates to maintain functionality for a reasonable period. For services, the service must be performed with reasonable care and skill, using proper materials. If it is not, you have the right to have it re-done or to receive a price reduction. The two-year minimum warranty period applies here as well, starting from the completion of the service or the provision of the digital content.
Can I return a product just because I don’t like it?
No, the legal warranty is not the same as a right of withdrawal or a “change of mind” return policy. The legal warranty only applies when there is a defect or a lack of conformity. If you simply do not like the colour, the size, or you have changed your mind, you cannot use the legal warranty as grounds for a return. However, for online purchases, you do have a separate, statutory 14-day right of withdrawal (cooling-off period) that allows you to return most goods for any reason. It is crucial not to confuse these two distinct legal rights.
What is the difference between the right of withdrawal and legal warranty?
The right of withdrawal is a 14-day period during which you can return an online purchase for any reason, even just because you changed your mind. It’s about giving you a chance to inspect the goods away from a physical shop. The legal warranty, on the other hand, is a long-term protection (min. 2 years) against defects that existed at the time of delivery. Withdrawal is for non-faulty goods; warranty is for faulty goods. You can exercise your right of withdrawal and then later, if you discover a hidden defect, still make a warranty claim after the withdrawal period has ended.
Do I need to provide the original packaging for a warranty claim?
No, you are generally not legally required to have the original packaging to make a valid warranty claim. The seller may request it to facilitate a return for logistical reasons, but they cannot deny your legal rights if you no longer have it. Your obligation is to return the product in a reasonable manner that allows the seller to inspect it. Using suitable alternative packaging to protect the item during transit is perfectly acceptable. The core of the claim is the defective product itself, not its box.
Who pays for the return shipping under legal warranty?
When returning a product because it is defective under the legal warranty, the seller is responsible for all costs associated with the return, including shipping. The seller must not charge you for sending the item back, for the repair, or for the shipping of a replacement. Any attempt to pass these costs on to you is a violation of your statutory rights. This is a key difference from using the 14-day right of withdrawal, where you are typically responsible for the cost of return shipping unless the seller has chosen to offer it for free.
What happens to the warranty if I sell my business?
If you sell your webshop business, the legal warranty obligations for all products sold by the previous owner transfer to the new owner. The consumer’s contract is with the business entity, not the individual. The new owner acquires all assets and liabilities, including outstanding warranty claims. This is a critical point for due diligence during a business acquisition. The new owner cannot refuse a valid warranty claim by stating “I didn’t sell you this.” This is why using a structured system to track past orders and potential claims is essential for any business transfer.
How do I prove the date of purchase for a warranty claim?
Your proof of purchase is the primary evidence for the date of purchase and delivery. This is most commonly an invoice or a receipt, which can be digital. Bank or credit card statements can also serve as supporting evidence. For online purchases, the order confirmation email and any shipping notification with a delivery date are crucial. It is your responsibility as the consumer to keep this documentation safe for the entire warranty period. Sellers are legally required to provide you with an invoice for every transaction, so always ensure you receive and save one.
Are there different warranty rules for B2B sales?
Yes, the legal warranty protections described here apply specifically to sales from a business to a consumer (B2C). In business-to-business (B2B) transactions, the rules are fundamentally different and are governed by the terms of the contract between the two companies. The mandatory two-year warranty and the burden of proof rules do not automatically apply. Businesses are expected to negotiate their own terms regarding defects, liability, and remedies. This is why it’s vital for webshops to clearly identify if they are selling to consumers or other businesses, as the legal framework shifts completely.
What is a conformity period in legal warranty?
The conformity period refers to the minimum two-year duration during which the seller is liable for a lack of conformity in the product. The core idea is that the product must remain in conformity with the sales contract for this period. If a defect appears within this time, and it is proven to have existed at delivery (easier in the first six months), the seller is responsible. Some legal interpretations suggest that for certain products, like a car or a washing machine, you can reasonably expect them to last for several years, which can influence claims even late in the warranty period.
Can a seller limit the legal warranty in their terms and conditions?
No, a seller cannot legally limit, waive, or exclude the statutory legal warranty through their general terms and conditions or any other agreement. Any clause in a contract that attempts to shorten the two-year period, exclude certain types of defects, or impose additional burdens on the consumer beyond what the law allows is considered null and void. The legal warranty is a mandatory protection for consumers, and its core provisions cannot be contracted away. Sellers who include such clauses are creating a false sense of security for themselves and misleading consumers.
How does legal warranty work for software and subscriptions?
For software sold on a physical medium or as a digital download, the legal warranty requires it to function as described and be free from defects that prevent its core use. For software-as-a-service (SaaS) or subscriptions, the warranty applies to the continuous provision of the service. If the service is repeatedly unavailable, lacks promised features, or suffers from critical security flaws, this constitutes a lack of conformity. Your remedies can include having the service fixed, a price reduction for the downtime, or a cancellation and refund if the failures are fundamental.
What are the seller’s obligations when a warranty claim is made?
Upon receiving a valid warranty claim, the seller has a clear set of obligations. They must respond to the consumer promptly and without undue delay. They must propose a solution to bring the product into conformity, which is typically the consumer’s choice of repair or replacement. This must be done free of charge, covering all costs including shipping. If these primary solutions fail, they must offer a price reduction or a full refund. The seller must also not cause the consumer significant inconvenience during the process. Failure to meet these obligations can lead to penalties and liability.
Does legal warranty cover wear and tear of clothing?
The legal warranty does not cover normal wear and tear that occurs from the correct use of clothing over time. For example, the gradual fading of colour from repeated washing or the thinning of fabric at stress points is generally considered wear and tear. However, if a seam unravels after the first wear, a zip breaks under normal use, or colour bleeds excessively in the first wash, these are likely inherent defects covered by the warranty. The key is whether the issue is a result of a manufacturing fault present at delivery or a consequence of normal use.
What if a product has a design fault that affects all models?
If a product has a widespread design or manufacturing fault that affects an entire batch or model line, it represents a clear lack of conformity. Every consumer who purchased a unit from that faulty batch has a valid warranty claim against the seller. The seller is obligated to provide a remedy for all affected customers, which could be a repair (if a modification is possible), a replacement with a corrected model, or a refund. Often in these situations, manufacturers issue a public recall or service campaign, but your direct legal claim for a remedy remains with the seller you bought it from.
How do I handle warranty claims for customers in other EU countries?
When you sell cross-border within the EU, you must respect the legal warranty rules of the consumer’s country of residence. While the EU has harmonized the minimum two-year period, national laws can differ on details like the burden of proof timeline or specific procedural rules. This creates a complex compliance landscape. The simplest and most robust approach is to adhere to the highest standard among the countries you sell to. Using a centralized compliance service can automate and manage these varying requirements, ensuring you don’t accidentally violate a foreign consumer’s rights.
Can a seller ask for a fee to assess a warranty claim?
No, a seller cannot charge any fee for assessing or processing a legal warranty claim. All costs related to verifying the defect, including inspection and testing, must be borne by the seller. This is a fundamental part of the consumer’s right to a free-of-charge remedy. If a seller insists on an “inspection fee” before even looking at the product, they are acting unlawfully. The only scenario where a consumer might bear a cost is if an inspection conclusively proves that there is no defect and the product was damaged by the consumer, but even this is subject to national law limitations.
What is the statute of limitations for legal warranty claims?
It is crucial to distinguish the warranty period from the statute of limitations. The legal warranty period is the minimum two-year window during which you can report a defect that existed at delivery. The statute of limitations is a longer period within which you must actually file a lawsuit in court to enforce your rights if the seller refuses. This limitation period is typically longer than two years (often 3-5 years, depending on the country) and starts from the moment you discovered, or should have discovered, the defect and the responsible party. You must report the defect within the 2-year warranty period, but you may have longer to sue.
How does legal warranty apply to custom-made or personalized products?
The legal warranty fully applies to custom-made or personalized products. The product must still be free from material or workmanship defects and fit for its purpose. However, you cannot claim a lack of conformity based on a feature that was part of your specific custom order instructions. For example, if you ordered a blue sofa and it arrives with a faulty frame, that’s a defect. But if you ordered it in a specific shade of blue and then decide you don’t like the colour, that is not a defect. The warranty covers the quality and durability of the item, not your subjective satisfaction with the design choices you specified.
What are the consequences for a seller who ignores warranty law?
A seller who systematically ignores or violates legal warranty obligations faces significant consequences. They can be subject to enforcement actions from national consumer protection authorities, resulting in substantial fines and mandatory compliance orders. They will also likely develop a poor reputation, leading to negative reviews and loss of customer trust. In many jurisdictions, consumers can claim additional compensation for damages suffered due to the seller’s refusal to comply. In severe cases, it can lead to injunctions against trading. For this reason, building a compliant and efficient warranty process from the start is not just good ethics, it’s sound business strategy.
About the author:
With over a decade of hands-on experience in e-commerce compliance and consumer law, the author has advised hundreds of online businesses on building legally sound operations. Their practical, no-nonsense approach focuses on implementing systems that protect both the consumer and the seller, turning legal obligations into a competitive advantage. They are a recognized voice on the operational realities of running a compliant webshop in the European market.
Geef een reactie